Let the model report a verdict per must-have and cap career at 39 in code when one is broken

The judge numbers an agent's must-haves (one per line) and answers met, broken or unclear for each; career is stored as the model gave it and counts as at most BROKEN_CAP when a role is served, in cv_score, Store.judgement and the SQL of Best CV match. Migration 29 adds role_judgements.musts and broken; the judge's input_key carries a format version so earlier judgements are made again. The reader lists the must-haves with their verdicts and the cap.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
WolfandClaude Sonnet 5.5 committed 2026-10-03 22:40:54 +02:00
1 parent 64fecf57ad
commit 001fc9002b
19 files changed
+336 -61

No files matched your search

+1 -1
View File
@@ -208,7 +208,7 @@ What was decided for roledesk and the one reason for each. The longer reasoning
**`extract_batch` and `summarise_batch` are `isolate=True`, with a timeout.** `context.check()` only runs between the calls `modeltask.one` makes, not inside one, so a call that hangs on either backend was otherwise unkillable short of restarting the server; a process boundary is what lets a Kill, or the timeout itself, actually end it. One call is already bounded at `agent.timeout`, so the deadline is a few calls' worth (30 minutes for extract, 15 for summarise): a batch still running after that is stuck, not slow. The cost: an isolated job's context has no working `stop`, `task` or `fan_out` (see `pipeline/child.py`'s `context_for`), so a refusal or an account-level failure inside a batch can no longer stop the rest of that task's queued siblings, which run on to the same failure instead of being spared it.
**A third order, Best CV match, from a model reading each agent's best roles against its CV (2026-10-03).** Taken from the `/rank` of github.com/MadsLorentzen/ai-job-search, which has a model score a posting against a written profile on five dimensions. Fit compares topics; it cannot tell a step down, years of experience or a stated deal-breaker, which a model reading both texts can. An agent may hold a CV (pasted, or a `.md`/`.txt` file the browser reads into the box), its languages with a level (suggested from the CV by one model call, then edited), an "avoid / drains me" text and a "must-haves and deal-breakers" text; the prompts stay what the owner wants. The stage `judge` (after summarise in the pull, switched under Runs like extract, Haiku by default) reads the pairs of an enabled agent with a CV within its `judge_top` and `judge_min` limits, once per `input_key` (a hash of the CV, prompts, both texts and the role's text), and stores skills, experience and career (0 to 100, their rubric bands verbatim), 1 to 3 strengths and gaps in `role_judgements`, which rescoring and closing never touch. The CV match is the weighted mean of the three, with the weights per agent (`cv_skills`, `cv_experience`, `cv_career` in `agents.weights`, default 30, 25, 30) applied when a role is served, so changing them needs no model call. Culture is left out (guessed from ad text) and location too (the gates do it): a must-haves text that names a place makes the model mark location down, so places belong in the Where rules. Haiku does not always hold the deal-breaker band (0 to 39 for career); a stronger model or a clamp in code is the fix if that matters. Their scale is ten postings a run; ours is the top of a ranking that has already scored every role for free.
**A third order, Best CV match, from a model reading each agent's best roles against its CV (2026-10-03).** Taken from the `/rank` of github.com/MadsLorentzen/ai-job-search, which has a model score a posting against a written profile on five dimensions. Fit compares topics; it cannot tell a step down, years of experience or a stated deal-breaker, which a model reading both texts can. An agent may hold a CV (pasted, or a `.md`/`.txt` file the browser reads into the box), its languages with a level (suggested from the CV by one model call, then edited), an "avoid / drains me" text and a "must-haves and deal-breakers" text; the prompts stay what the owner wants. The stage `judge` (after summarise in the pull, switched under Runs like extract, Haiku by default) reads the pairs of an enabled agent with a CV within its `judge_top` and `judge_min` limits, once per `input_key` (a hash of the CV, prompts, both texts and the role's text), and stores skills, experience and career (0 to 100, their rubric bands verbatim), 1 to 3 strengths and gaps in `role_judgements`, which rescoring and closing never touch. The CV match is the weighted mean of the three, with the weights per agent (`cv_skills`, `cv_experience`, `cv_career` in `agents.weights`, default 30, 25, 30) applied when a role is served, so changing them needs no model call. Culture is left out (guessed from ad text) and location too (the gates do it): a must-haves text that names a place makes the model mark location down, so places belong in the Where rules. The model reports facts and code applies the rules: the must-haves text is read as one must-have per line (leading bullets and numbers dropped), the judge's profile numbers them M1..Mn, and for each judgement the model answers `musts`, a verdict per must-have, "met", "broken" only when the posting text clearly contradicts it, or "unclear" when the text does not say (never inferred from silence; a must-have the model leaves out counts as unclear). It scores career on its rubric as before and the career is stored as given. The cap is code's: when a role is served, any "broken" verdict makes career count as `min(career, BROKEN_CAP)` with `BROKEN_CAP = 39` (`app.models`), in `cv_score`, in `Store.judgement` (which serves the model's career, `career_capped` and the must-haves with their text) and in `store._cv_sql`, which reads a `broken` count stored beside the verdicts (`role_judgements.musts` and `.broken`, migration 29), so Best CV match orders by the capped value too. The verdicts store each line's text, so the reader still shows the must-haves a judgement was made against after the text is edited. The judge's `input_key` carries a format version (`judge.FORMAT`, 2), so judgements made before the verdicts existed are made again; until then they serve with no must-haves and no cap. The reader shows each must-have with ✓ met, ✗ broken or ? unclear, and career as "39 (capped: breaks a must-have; model said 55)". Their scale is ten postings a run; ours is the top of a ranking that has already scored every role for free.
**A posting's languages and deadline, and a flag rather than a score.** Extract reads `languages_required` as objects (language, level on the ladder basic, conversational, professional, fluent, native, and required or plus) and a deadline, from the opening and the closing lines of the text, since both usually sit at the end. Jobnet and Jobbank state a deadline, kept as `deadline_host`; prep composes `deadline` host first. The language flag is computed when a role is served from the posting's languages and the agent's: ⚠ when a required one is missing or its level is above the agent's, ★ when a plus one is the agent's; it never changes a score. Closing soon is the deadline from today to today plus four days, in UTC.